That Other Gharana

Blog Writer: 
Pranav Yajnik

For those of us raised on Kathak in the United Kingdom, the Banaras gharana is a strange, wild creature.  Glimpsed only through clips on the internet, the Caliban of Kathak seems to creep and crawl around the perimeter on the fringes of our known world, never fully seen but at times presenting itself as an 'other' that beguiles as much as it perplexes.  The prevailing style of Kathak in the United Kingdom is Lucknow gharana, regardless of the sub-style the teachers take their training in.  Opportunities to see and learn Jaipur gharana are rare; Banaras gharana, near impossible.  I was, therefore, reasonably intrigued when it came to my attention that Jayanti Mala, daughter of the notorious Kathak dancer Sitara Devi, would perform as part of the Alla Rakha Foundation's concert at the Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan at the end of last month.  I've seen enough bad Kathak to know that a dancer's claims about his or her lineage have no bearing on their ability to dance.  The doubts I had at the start of the performance were blown to powder in the first five minutes; and here I must skip to the end of the performance to explain why.

 
"It wasn't very refined," said someone on their way out.  Damn right it wasn't.  There was none of the smarmy, unctuous 'purity' of line which other styles advocate; none of the chloroform of sanitised movements which drip onto an audience blinking in the glare of the stage lights like patients in an operating theatre.  What was there may have seemed raw, but it was warm, it was honest and it was clear.  Every single tukra bol could be heard on the ghunghru; Jayanti Mala couldn't restrain herself from joining in with Yogesh Shamsi-ji's tabla; and it was a rare delight to see her unrestrained abhinaya when dancing the Banaras gharana speciality of kavit.  Not only that, but a small nuclear facility seemed to be supplying her dance with power (so much so that the safety-valve venting of some steam resulted in an on-stage spat between her and Abhay Shankar Mishra, who was accompanying her on the pakhavaj).  
 
In fact on second thoughts, in this context, I would problematise the concept of 'refinement' (as well as my assertion above that the performance wasn't refined).   What's refinement anyway?  A quick search of the internet dictionaries (which has somewhat depressingly replaced my Concise OED for convenience) renders the following: '1. fineness or elegance of feeling, taste, manners, language, etc; 2. an instance of refined feeling, manners, etc; 3. the act or process of refining; 4. the quality or state of being refined; 5. a subtle point or distinction; 6. subtle reasoning.'  Leaving aside 3, 4, and 6 as perhaps not directly applicable, I would find it hard to argue that Jayanti Mala's dance had no fineness to it, no subtle points and no distinction.  In fact, a fellow dancer of considerable experience was amazed at the abhinaya and the coquetry that Jayanti Mala presented, as things that my friend herself found hard to do even as a long-trained dancer in Bharatanatyam.  
 
There were refinements and niceties galore; but they are details to which we are unaccustomed.  Her 'Hori' abhinaya piece was filled with old-world Kathak, such that is rarely seen nowadays and that evoked the charm of a bygone time.  The tukras she presented were filled with intricacies, not only of technique but of expression.  Her presentation was bold, brassy and Banaras.  
 
The dare is to accept that sometimes things may not be as 'graceless' or 'unrefined' as they may first seem, to accept that they are merely refined in different ways, ways to which we are unused, ways which may take us out of our comfort zone into new modes of viewing and appreciating the same dance we thought we knew so well.  As Kumi-ben says, 'There is no right or wrong in dance; there is only good dance and bad dance.'  I hope she'd agree that this was unarguably good dance.  
 
And as for Banaras gharana: 'Be not afeard; the isle is full of noises, Sounds, and sweet airs, that give delight and hurt not'.
 

Comments

Andada

boston celtics jersey

nike outlet

replica watches

skechers shoes

converse trainers

ugg outlet

coach outlet

nike shoes

michael kors uk

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ugg boots

hugo boss sale

ugg boots

versace jeans

fitflops sale

ferragamo outlet

nike factory outlet

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin shoes

ugg boots

ugg boots

mbt shoes outlet

michael kors outlet

true religion outlet

ugg boots

minnesota vikings jerseys

cowboys jerseys

cheap ugg boots

michael kors handbags outlet

ugg boots

michael kors handbags

ray ban sunglasses

true religion outlet

new england patriots jerseys

michael kors handbags

oakley sunglasses

cheap jordan shoes

jordan shoes

omega watches sale

bills jerseys

coach factory outlet

sac longchamp

michael kors outlet

converse trainers

ugg boots

nike huarache

yeezy boost 350 white

pandora outlet

ugg outlet

pittsburgh steelers jersey

oakland raiders jerseys

nike blazer

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

fitflops sale

ed hardy uk

michael kors uk

new york knicks jersey

jordan shoes

green bay packers jerseys

replica watches

ugg boots

nike free run

49ers jersey

michael kors handbags

mont blanc outlet

jerseys wholesale

carolina jerseys

michael kors handbags

ralph lauren uk

michael kors outlet online

louis vuitton sacs

ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet

miami heat jersey

jerseys wholesale

jimmy choo shoes

moncler jackets

cheap nfl jerseys

nike store

coach outlet

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

nike blazer

ugg boots

nike air huarache

jordan 4

michael kors outlet

ugg boots

rolex replica

michael kors bags

sac longchamp

louboutin shoes

ferragamo outlet

ugg outlet

nike shoes

ralph lauren

cheap basketball shoes

ugg boots

michael kors handbags

coach outlet online

gucci shoes

nike trainers

ugg outlet

nhl jerseys

kate spade sale

mont blanc outlet

nike outlet

air jordan uk

clippers jersey

kate spade sale

nike air force 1

ugg boots

ugg boots

ed hardy

ecco outlet

coach outlet store online

longchamp handbags

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

mlb jerseys

michael kors purses

valentino outlet

michael kors bags

true religion outlet

baltimore ravens jerseys

polo ralph lauren

true religion outlet

nike shoes

ugg boots

adidas nmd

longchamp outlet

oakley sunglasses

jordan 8

michael kors handbags

ugg boots

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

ecco outlet

michael kors uk

michael kors purses

cheap nfl jerseys

fitflops

ray ban sunglasses outlet

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet

nike store

michael kors handbags

jacksonville jaguars jersey

golden state warriors jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

true religion outlet store

nike air huarache

nike huarache

pandora outlet

michael kors uk

ugg boots

saics running shoes

new balance shoes

cheap basketball shoes

prada outlet

nike factory outlet

redskins jerseys

pandora outlet

coach outlet

ugg boots

yeezy shoes

michael kors outlet

valentino outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

hugo boss suits

jets jersey

nike huarache

nike air force 1

kobe 9

hugo boss suits

coach outlet

ugg outlet

chiefs jersey

ray ban sunglasses outlet

polo ralph lauren

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

ugg boots

nike shoes

ugg boots

christian louboutin sale

cheap oakley sunglasses

supra sneakers

ugg boots

arizona cardinals jerseys

ugg outlet

san antonio spurs jerseys

new orleans saints jerseys

coach outlet online

michael kors uk

ray ban sunglasses

longchamp outlet

mont blanc outlet

ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

nike roshe

ugg boots

adidas nmd

skechers shoes

ugg boots

nike outlet

armani exchange

ralph lauren uk

ed hardy uk

nike air max 90

oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren outlet

moncler jackets

ugg outlet

jordan shoes

fitflops sale

eagles jerseys

coach outlet

houston texans jerseys

ugg outlet

toms shoes

hugo boss sale

hermes belts

snapbacks wholesale

ed hardy

michael kors handbags

coach outlet online

los angeles lakers jerseys

jordan 4

ugg boots

hermes belts

michael kors outlet

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

jordan 4

chicago bulls jersey

christian louboutin shoes

yeezy shoes

christian louboutin sale

christian louboutin shoes

louis vuitton sacs

ugg outlet

atlanta falcons jerseys

michael kors bags

pandora jewelry

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

polo ralph lauren

polo ralph lauren

polo ralph lauren

nike blazer pas cher

polo ralph lauren

giants jersey

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors bags

ugg outlet

jordan 8

prada outlet

ralph lauren uk

jordan shoes

coach outlet

ugg boots

nike huarache

nba jerseys

coach outlet

ugg boots

ugg outlet

nike free run

mlb jerseys

coach outlet store online

michael kors outlet

armani exchange

nike shoes

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren polo

oakley sunglasses

jordan shoes

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors handbags outlet

rolex replica watches

ugg outlet

coach outlet store

jordan shoes

michael kors uk

nike blazer pas cher

fitflops

dolphins jerseys

ugg boots

louboutin shoes

ugg outlet

kate spade outlet

ugg outlet

nike huarache

gucci sito ufficiale

michael kors uk

ugg boots

gucci shoes

nike trainers

nhl jerseys

michael kors handbags

coach outlet

nike roshe

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

christian louboutin shoes

yeezy boost 350 white

michael kors outlet

cheap ugg boots

nike outlet

reebok shoes

michael kors handbags

fitflops shoes

jordan shoes

bengals jersey

ugg boots

mbt shoes outlet

kate spade sale

air jordan uk

pandora outlet

louboutin shoes

adidas nmd

ralph lauren outlet

ugg boots

fitflops

cheap ugg boots

coach outlet

nba jerseys

coach outlet

colts jerseys

ugg boots

ugg boots

chargers jerseys

new balance shoes

oakley sunglasses

kate spade outlet

coach outlet online

ugg boots

mont blanc outlet

broncos jerseys

ugg outlet

coach outlet

ray ban sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

ray ban sunglasses outlet

nike trainers

mont blanc outlet

michael kors bags

coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses

true religion outlet store

coach outlet

detroit lions jerseys

nike trainers

kate spade sale

ralph lauren uk

ugg outlet

michael kors bags

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

ugg boots

nike tn

nike air max 90

coach outlet

ugg boots

ray ban sunglasses outlet

mont blanc outlet

ugg outlet

adidas nmd

ugg outlet

polo ralph lauren

jimmy choo shoes

oakley sunglasses

tennessee titans jersey

ralph lauren

ray ban sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren outlet

ray ban sunglasses

rolex replica

polo ralph lauren outlet

cheap ugg boots

gucci sito ufficiale

ray ban sunglasses outlet

nike tn

ugg outlet

reebok shoes

coach bags

nike outlet

ugg boots

ugg boots

true religion outlet

kobe 9

michael kors handbags

seahawks jersey

ugg outlet

oakley sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

fitflops shoes

nike outlet

rolex replica watches

michael kors uk

ugg boots

bears jerseys

ugg boots

christian louboutin shoes

fitflops

nike outlet

nike huarache

cheap jordan shoes

coach bags

fitflops sale

ralph lauren outlet

omega watches sale

versace jeans

supra sneakers

cheap oakley sunglasses

toms shoes

louboutin shoes

coach outlet store

oklahoma city thunder jerseys

michael kors outlet

browns jerseys

jordan 4

ugg outlet

nike outlet

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses

rolex watches

coach outlet

rolex watches

jordan shoes

saics running shoes

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

true religion outlet

snapbacks wholesale

nike shoes

ugg outlet

ralph lauren polo

coach outlet online

longchamp handbags

These are some great tools

These are some great tools that i definitely use for SEO work. This is a great list to use in the future.. my response

It is imperative that we read

It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing. http://www.strategyandmarketing.ca

Wonderful illustrated

Wonderful illustrated information. I thank you about that. No doubt it will be very useful for my future projects. Would like to see some other posts on the same subject! Jason Michael Spencer

This is a great inspiring

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. dgbloggers.com

Well Aaron likes this article

If you ever wonder or think about finding new Android games then I guess you need to use Blackmart App Download for Android

biography writing services

Nice share. I think your website biography writing services should come up much higher in the search results than where it is showing up right now….

Dịch vụ điện hoa đẹp tận nơi

Dịch vụ điện hoa đẹp tận nơi miễn phí có tại Shop Hoa Tươi TPHCM. Shop hoa TPHCM luôn mang tới cho thị trường những sản phẩm hoa tươi đa dạng các loài và những bông hoa chất lượng nhất. Shop hoa tươi đẹp chúng tôi không chỉ phục vụ khu vực tại một khu vực mà còn bao gồm tất cả khu vực trong hcm như quận 1, quận 2, quận 3, quận 4, quận 5, quận 6, quận 7, quận 8, quận 9, quận 10, quận bình thạnh, quận tân phú…Trong nội TPHCM http://hoatuoishop.net/

minimilitia

good God Mod won't allow you pass away. For a beginner Download Mini Militia APK with the data here Metro Tricks is concerned Total nice.

welcome

reply

The article does contain important things related to Kathak and thanks for sharing the details on Banaras gharana and Jaipur gharana. Sitara Devi is well known for her performance in Kathak and hope you will share more valuable pieces of writings like the same. comcast xfinity

good interaction to hook up

good interaction to hook up it page which enable end Xender App this application to exchange distinct media, Zip nice.

good The additional

good The additional alternative that will do the job very well snapchat hidden filters to the program at all circumstances, possibly when great.

محبى وعشاق العاب تلبيس نقدم

محبى وعشاق العاب تلبيس نقدم لكم اللعبة الأكثر تمييزاً بين جميع العاب بنات والخاصة بتلبيس هنديات بالثوب الهندى المميز والرائع والأكثر رغبة لدى الكثير فى تلبيسه al3ab banat العاب بنات تلبيس العاب جديدة

العاب

إن ألعاب الفلاش تعرف تطورا كبيرا، خصوصا في مجال الجرافيك والأداء، لقد أصبح الإهتمام بهندسة الصورة من الأولويات، إضافة إلى البحث عن الإمتاع في اللعبة، وهذا ما ستلمسه في لعبة خرجت سنة 2016 وهي لعبة الدبابة المدمرة، إحدى روائع موقع العاب سيارات الحربية. العاب سيارات لعب العاب سيارات 2017 al3ab العاب تلبيس بنات العاب باربي العاب فلاش العاب عربيات

An interesting topic you have

An interesting topic you have discussed. I always like your posts and the information shared in it. car parking luton airport